Who vs. That: What’s the Difference? Rules, Examples, and Common Mistakes

November 16, 2026
Written By James Carter

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur pulvinar ligula augue quis venenatis. 

Understanding the difference between who vs. that is an important part of learning English grammar. Both words are used in sentences to identify people or provide additional information. However, they do not always have the same meaning or grammatical function. Choosing the correct word can make your writing clearer, more natural, and grammatically accurate.

The main difference is simple: who is generally used to refer to people, while that can refer to people, animals, and things in restrictive relative clauses. For example, you would normally write, “The woman who lives next door is a teacher.” However, you can also say, “The woman that lives next door is a teacher.”

Although both sentences are grammatically acceptable, there are situations where only one word is appropriate. For instance, who is preferred in nonrestrictive relative clauses, which provide extra information about someone. Similarly, that is commonly used in essential clauses that identify a particular person or thing.

In this guide, you will learn the difference between who and that, their definitions, sentence structures, grammar rules, and practical examples. You will also discover common mistakes, understand how these words connect with relative clauses and English tenses, and learn how to use them confidently in everyday conversations, academic writing, and professional communication.

Table of Contents

Definition of Who and That

To understand who vs. that, it is helpful to examine the meaning and grammatical function of each word separately.

What Does Who Mean?

Who is a relative pronoun and an interrogative pronoun used to refer to people.

As a relative pronoun, who introduces a relative clause that gives information about a person. It can function as the subject of that clause.

Examples:

  • The boy who won the competition is my cousin.
  • I know a woman who speaks five languages.
  • The teacher who helped me is very kind.
  • She is the student who received the highest score.

In these examples, who refers to a person and connects additional information to the main noun.

What Does That Mean?

That can function as a relative pronoun, demonstrative pronoun, demonstrative determiner, or conjunction, depending on its use.

When comparing who vs. that, we are mainly interested in its role as a relative pronoun.

It introduces a restrictive relative clause that provides essential information about a person, animal, or thing.

Examples:

  • The man that called you is my uncle.
  • The book that I purchased is interesting.
  • The dog that lives here is friendly.
  • The employee that works upstairs is helpful.

In these sentences, that introduces information needed to identify the person, animal, or thing being discussed.

Sentence Structure of Who vs. That

Both who and that can introduce relative clauses. However, their use depends on the type of clause and the noun they describe.

Understanding their sentence structure makes it easier to choose the correct relative pronoun.

Basic Sentence Structure With Who

The common sentence pattern using who is:

Noun (person) + who + verb + additional information

Examples:

  • The girl who sings beautifully is my sister.
  • The doctor who treated me was professional.
  • The man who lives across the street is friendly.

Here, who acts as the subject of the relative clause.

Another structure uses who as an object:

Noun (person) + who + subject + verb

Examples:

  • The woman who I met yesterday is a lawyer.
  • The student who we invited is absent.
  • The person who they selected is experienced.

In everyday English, whom is also traditionally used as an object pronoun, especially in formal writing.

Basic Sentence Structure With That

The common sentence pattern using that is:

Noun + that + subject or verb + additional information

Examples:

  • The movie that we watched was exciting.
  • The person that called me was polite.
  • The house that stands on the hill is beautiful.

That can introduce both subject and object relative clauses.

However, remember that that is not normally used in nonrestrictive relative clauses.

Important Grammar Rules for Who vs. That

Learning a few simple rules will help you understand when to use who and when to use that.

Rule 1: Use Who for People

Use who when referring to people, particularly in formal writing and when the person is the subject of the relative clause.

Examples:

  • The woman who teaches English is friendly.
  • I know a boy who plays football.
  • The manager who hired me is experienced.
  • The author who wrote this book is famous.

Who is often the safest and most natural choice when describing people.

Rule 2: Use That in Restrictive Relative Clauses

A restrictive relative clause provides essential information about a noun. Without this information, the reader might not know exactly which person or thing you mean.

That can introduce restrictive clauses referring to people.

Examples:

  • The employee that arrived late missed the meeting.
  • The person that helped us was generous.
  • The student that answered correctly received a prize.

In these sentences, the clauses identify particular people.

Rule 3: Use Who in Nonrestrictive Relative Clauses

A nonrestrictive relative clause provides additional information that is not essential to identifying the person.

Use who rather than that in this type of clause.

Examples:

  • My brother, who lives in Chicago, is a doctor.
  • Sarah, who works at the hospital, is my friend.
  • Mr. Brown, who teaches mathematics, is very patient.

Notice that commas separate the extra information from the main sentence.

Incorrect: My brother, that lives in Chicago, is a doctor.

Correct: My brother, who lives in Chicago, is a doctor.

Rule 4: Do Not Use That After a Comma in Relative Clauses

When a relative clause is nonrestrictive, that is not the correct choice.

Incorrect: My father, that is a teacher, enjoys reading.

Correct: My father, who is a teacher, enjoys reading.

The comma indicates that the information is additional rather than essential.

Rule 5: Use That for Things and Animals

Unlike who, that can refer to objects, animals, and other nonhuman nouns in restrictive relative clauses.

Examples:

  • The phone that I bought is expensive.
  • The cat that sleeps outside belongs to my neighbor.
  • The car that broke down is mine.
  • The flowers that you planted look beautiful.

This is one of the clearest differences between the two words.

Who vs. That: Examples in Everyday English

Examples make grammar rules easier to understand. Here are practical sentences showing how who and that work in everyday communication.

10 Examples of Who

  1. The teacher who teaches science is very helpful.
  2. I met a woman who works in a bank.
  3. The boy who won the race is my friend.
  4. She is the doctor who treated my mother.
  5. The man who lives next door is a writer.
  6. Students who study regularly usually perform better.
  7. The girl who called you is waiting outside.
  8. My uncle, who lives in Texas, visits us every summer.
  9. The employee who completed the project received a bonus.
  10. People who exercise regularly often feel healthier.

10 Examples of That

  1. The man that called yesterday is my neighbor.
  2. The student that answered the question was correct.
  3. The book that I borrowed is interesting.
  4. The car that belongs to my brother is red.
  5. The dog that barked all night was hungry.
  6. The movie that we watched was entertaining.
  7. The woman that works here is very friendly.
  8. The phone that I purchased stopped working.
  9. The house that we visited was beautiful.
  10. The person that helped me was very kind.

Examples Using Both Who and That

In restrictive relative clauses referring to people, both words can sometimes be used.

  • The man who called me is my teacher.
  • The man that called me is my teacher.
  • The girl who won the award is my sister.
  • The girl that won the award is my sister.
  • The employee who works here is experienced.
  • The employee that works here is experienced.

Both versions are grammatically acceptable in standard English. However, who is often preferred when referring to people, especially in formal writing.

Comparison Table: Who vs. That

The following table summarizes the main differences between who and that.

Grammar FeatureWhoThat
Refers to peopleYesYes
Refers to animalsNot normallyYes
Refers to thingsNoYes
Used in restrictive clausesYesYes
Used in nonrestrictive clausesYesNo
Used after a comma in relative clausesYesNo
Used as a relative pronounYesYes
Preferred for people in formal writingYesLess commonly

Who vs. That: Quick Examples

SentenceCorrect Choice
The woman ___ teaches me is kind.Who
The book ___ I read was interesting.That
My brother, ___ lives in New York, is a doctor.Who
The dog ___ barked is outside.That
The student ___ won the prize is happy.Who or That

Quick tip: If you are talking about a person, who is usually the best choice. If you are referring to an object or animal, that can be used in a restrictive relative clause.

Common Mistakes When Using Who and That

Common Mistakes When Using Who and That

English learners sometimes confuse who and that because both can refer to people. Here are some frequent mistakes and their corrections.

Mistake 1: Using That in a Nonrestrictive Clause

Incorrect: My sister, that lives in London, is a nurse.

Correct: My sister, who lives in London, is a nurse.

Explanation: A nonrestrictive clause adds extra information and requires who when referring to a person.

Mistake 2: Using Who for Objects

Incorrect: This is the phone who I purchased yesterday.

Correct: This is the phone that I purchased yesterday.

Explanation: Who refers to people, not ordinary objects.

Mistake 3: Forgetting Commas

Incorrect: My teacher who lives nearby is very helpful.

Correct if the information is extra: My teacher, who lives nearby, is very helpful.

Explanation: When the relative clause provides additional information rather than identifying the teacher, commas are needed.

Mistake 4: Thinking That Is Always Wrong for People

Incorrect assumption: You can never use that for people.

Correct: The person that called me is my friend.

Explanation: That is acceptable in restrictive relative clauses referring to people.

Mistake 5: Confusing Who With Whom

Incorrect in formal grammar: The person whom called me is my friend.

Correct: The person who called me is my friend.

Explanation: Who functions as the subject of the relative clause. Whom is traditionally used as an object.

Verb Usage With Who and That

Understanding verbs is important when constructing sentences with relative pronouns.

Both who and that can introduce relative clauses containing different verb forms. The verb depends on the subject, the meaning, and the tense of the sentence.

Who or That as the Subject

When who or that acts as the subject, the verb follows it.

Examples:

  • The boy who plays football is my brother.
  • The woman who works here is friendly.
  • The person that lives upstairs is a teacher.
  • The employee that handles customer service is helpful.

Notice the subject-verb agreement:

  • The student who studies hard succeeds.
  • The students who study hard succeed.

Who or That as the Object

When the relative pronoun acts as the object, another subject comes before the verb.

Examples:

  • The man who I met was friendly.
  • The book that she purchased was expensive.
  • The woman that we invited arrived early.
  • The movie that they watched was excellent.

In informal English, the relative pronoun can sometimes be omitted when it functions as the object.

For example:

  • The book that I read was excellent.
  • The book I read was excellent.

Both sentences are correct.

Who vs. That and English Tenses

Who and that can be used with different English tenses. The relative pronoun does not determine the tense; the verb inside the relative clause does.

Understanding this relationship helps learners create accurate sentence structures.

Present Tense

Use present-tense verbs to describe regular actions, habits, or general facts.

Examples:

  • The woman who teaches English is kind.
  • The man that works here speaks Spanish.
  • Students who practice daily improve their skills.

Past Tense

Use past-tense verbs to describe completed actions or events.

Examples:

  • The person who called me yesterday was polite.
  • The student that won the competition received a medal.
  • The teacher who helped us was patient.

Future Tense

Relative clauses can also describe future actions.

Examples:

  • The person who will lead the meeting is my manager.
  • The student that will represent our school is talented.
  • The employee who will join tomorrow has experience.

Tense Comparison Table

TenseExample With WhoExample With That
PresentThe boy who plays here is happy.The dog that lives here is friendly.
PastThe man who visited us was kind.The car that stopped was expensive.
FutureThe woman who will teach us is arriving.The machine that will work automatically is new.
Present PerfectThe student who has finished can leave.The project that has started is important.
Past PerfectThe man who had called was waiting.The work that had started was incomplete.

Remember that other grammar topics, such as has vs have, the use of had, and future indefinite tense examples, involve different rules. However, they can all appear in sentences containing relative clauses.

Read More : Either vs. Neither: Meaning, Differences, Grammar Rules, and Examples

Clauses and Advanced Grammar Usage

To understand who vs. that completely, you should also understand relative clauses.

A clause is a group of words containing a subject and a verb. Relative clauses provide information about a noun or pronoun.

Restrictive Relative Clauses

A restrictive relative clause identifies exactly which person or thing is being discussed.

It is also called a defining relative clause.

Examples:

  • The woman who works at the school is my aunt.
  • The boy that broke the window apologized.
  • The phone that belongs to Sarah is missing.

These clauses are essential to the meaning of the sentences and do not require commas.

Nonrestrictive Relative Clauses

A nonrestrictive relative clause provides extra information about a person or thing that is already identified.

It is also called a non-defining relative clause.

Examples:

  • My mother, who is a teacher, loves reading.
  • John, who lives nearby, is my best friend.
  • My uncle, who works in Canada, visits every year.

Use commas around these clauses. When referring to people, use who rather than that.

Relative Pronoun as Subject and Object

Who and that can both act as the subject or object in restrictive relative clauses.

Subject example:

  • The boy who plays cricket is my cousin.
  • The man that works here is friendly.

Object example:

  • The boy who I invited is absent.
  • The book that I purchased is useful.

Understanding the difference between subject and object clauses will improve your overall English grammar and sentence structure.

Who vs. That in Formal and Informal English

Who vs. That in Formal and Informal English

Although who and that can both refer to people in restrictive clauses, their usage can differ depending on the writing situation.

Formal English

In formal writing, who is generally preferred when referring to people.

Examples:

  • The candidate who received the highest score was selected.
  • The researcher who conducted the study presented the results.
  • The employee who manages the department is responsible for the project.

Who sounds natural and is widely accepted in academic, professional, and business writing.

Informal English

In everyday conversations, people frequently use that when referring to people in restrictive clauses.

Examples:

  • The guy that called you is waiting.
  • The girl that lives next door is my friend.
  • The person that helped me was nice.

These sentences are grammatically acceptable.

Which One Should You Choose?

Use this simple guide:

  • Choose who when referring to people, especially in formal writing.
  • Choose that for things and animals in restrictive clauses.
  • Use who in nonrestrictive clauses about people.
  • Avoid using that immediately after a comma in a nonrestrictive relative clause.

Frequently Asked Questions About Who vs. That

1. What Is the Main Difference Between Who and That?

The main difference is their grammatical use. Who generally refers to people, while that can refer to people, animals, and things in restrictive relative clauses. Who is also required for nonrestrictive relative clauses referring to people.

2. Can I Use That for a Person?

Yes. You can use that to refer to a person in a restrictive relative clause.

Example: The man that helped me was very kind.

However, who is generally preferred when referring to people, particularly in formal writing.

3. Is Who More Formal Than That?

Generally, yes. Who is often preferred in formal, academic, and professional writing when describing people. That is also grammatically correct in restrictive clauses but is more common in casual language.

4. Can I Use Who After a Comma?

Yes. Who can introduce a nonrestrictive relative clause after a comma.

Example: My brother, who lives in New York, is a doctor.

The clause adds extra information about your brother.

5. Can I Use That After a Comma?

Not when that introduces a nonrestrictive relative clause.

Incorrect: My friend, that lives nearby, is a teacher.

Correct: My friend, who lives nearby, is a teacher.

6. Can Who and That Be Used Interchangeably?

Sometimes. Both can introduce restrictive relative clauses referring to people.

For example:

  • The woman who called me is my aunt.
  • The woman that called me is my aunt.

However, they cannot always replace each other. That cannot normally introduce nonrestrictive relative clauses, and who is not used for ordinary objects.

7. Which Is Correct: The Person Who or the Person That?

Both are correct when introducing a restrictive relative clause.

Examples:

  • The person who helped me is my friend.
  • The person that helped me is my friend.

Nevertheless, the person who is generally the more natural choice, especially in formal English.

8. What Is the Difference Between Who, Whom, and That?

Who generally functions as the subject of a relative clause, while whom traditionally functions as its object. That can function as either the subject or object in restrictive relative clauses.

Examples:

  • The man who called me is friendly.
  • The man whom I called is friendly.
  • The man that I called is friendly.

Conclusion

Understanding who vs. that is easier when you remember their basic grammatical functions. Who generally refers to people and is preferred in formal writing, while that can refer to people, animals, and things in restrictive relative clauses.

Both words can introduce essential information about a person, but only who is appropriate for nonrestrictive relative clauses referring to people. Remember that commas are important because they help distinguish essential information from additional details.

To improve your English grammar, practice using both relative pronouns in different sentence structures, present and past tenses, and everyday conversations. Pay attention to whether the clause identifies someone or simply provides extra information.

With regular practice, you will become more confident in choosing between who and that and writing clear, natural, and grammatically correct English sentences.

Leave a Comment